Run 14 November 2026, 10:42 to 12:46 UK. Scored 18 November 2026.

I asked ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, Gemini and Claude ten questions about current UK figures, then one follow-up: "When is that figure from? Give the month or period and the official source." In 80 of 80 chats, the second answer gave a period. When I sent a neutral follow-up instead, 7 of 64 did.

The lesson is simple. AI answers often know when a figure is from. They tell you if you ask.

The two predictions

CallWhat it saidResult
P19 (Right)76 or more of 80 second answers state a periodRight. 80 of 80. If a period must include a year, 75 of 80, which would be a miss by one. The registered test does not mention a year, so it is scored on the wording as written. Both counts are shown here.
P20 (Right)At least one period differs from the official period read the same dayRight. 3 of 80 did.
Both calls were written down on 14 October 2026 in the registered plan.

By engine

EngineAsked for the date: gave a periodOf those, with a yearPeriod wrongNeutral follow-up: gave a periodFirst answers with no date
ChatGPT20 of 202003 of 200 of 40
Google AI Mode20 of 202022 of 201 of 40
Gemini20 of 201500 of 2016 of 40
Claude20 of 202012 of 40 of 24
All80 of 807537 of 64 (3 more unclear)17 of 144
Arm D = the date follow-up. Arm N = "Thanks. Is there anything else I should know?". Claude arm N was cut short (see departures).
  • Gemini left the date off 16 of its 40 first answers. Asked, it gave one every time, but five times without a year ("August", "June to August", "October" twice, "the April annual release").
  • Of the 8 date-follow-up chats whose first answer had no date, all 8 gave a period when asked. Of the 9 neutral chats whose first answer had no date, none did.

The three wrong periods

  • Google AI Mode, UK population, twice: it led with 70.1 million "as of November 2026", a projection. The official figure is 69,483,900 for mid-2025 (ONS).
  • Claude, average house price, once: it dated the official £273,000 to July 2026. ONS gives it for the 12 months to August 2026. In the same answer it said a later release existed.

Two more answers gave several periods for several indices rather than one. They count as stating a period and are not counted as wrong.

Departures from the plan

  • Claude neutral arm: 4 of 20 chats. Scripts are not allowed on claude.ai, so each chat was typed and read by hand, and the run was stopped. P19 and P20 use the date arm only.
  • All four tools were used signed in (temporary or incognito chats), not signed out.
  • Nine ChatGPT chats were lost to a tool time-out and rerun. One chat was excluded because the follow-up was sent before the first answer finished, and rerun once.
  • For ChatGPT, AI Mode and Gemini I coded from the opening of each answer plus every date mention around it, not the full text. Claude answers were read in full. One coder, no second check.
  • The Ofgem price cap figure (£1,723, 1 October to 31 December 2026) was not stated on the Ofgem page I read, so that row is unconfirmed at source. All four engines gave the same figure and period.
  • Claude (Fable 5.2) ran the study and is one of the four tools tested.

What I will not claim

Ten questions, four tools, one morning. This does not show how often AI answers give out-of-date figures in general. It shows that, on these questions, asking for the date nearly always gets one, and that it was wrong 3 times in 80.

Data