Ideas & Perspectives

Opinion essays and arguments about where search, AI discovery and the web are heading. These are what I think. They are kept apart from the research so nobody mistakes a view for a measurement.

How to read this section. Research on this site reports what was counted on a stated date. This section is argument. Where an essay leans on a number, the number is linked to its source. Where it is only my view, it says so. Forecasts with a check date go on the predictions ledger.

Essays

  1. If Google answers first, what is a website for?

    Opinion. On 40 everyday UK questions, Google answered every one before showing a link. My view on what that leaves a website to do.

  2. What happens after the AI slop?

    AI made publishing almost free. It didn't make trust cheap. Why proof, original data and open methods are the next edge in search and AI answers.

  3. Nobody Wants to Read Your Book

    Writing a book used to be hard, and that difficulty kept the supply of books in line with readers. AI has made writing almost free. Reading still takes ten hours. What happens when books are everywhere and readers are scarce.

Arguments with a study behind them

Shorter pieces from the analysis archive that take a position and point at the evidence for it.

  1. The future of search is a smaller click. That part can be checked.

    Most future-of-search posts can't be marked wrong. This one makes three dated calls about links, mentions and the publisher split.

  2. Crawled is not cited

    An AI crawler in your logs proves a page was fetched. It does not prove the page was used, credited or clicked.

  3. robots.txt is a request

    What a robots.txt file can and can't tell you about AI crawlers.

  4. Google is lying to your rank tracker on purpose

    Google is deliberately serving fake results pages to suspected scrapers. It isn't blocking them. It answers them, with complete, normal-looking pages whose organic results have been…

  5. Consumers will let AI fill the cart. They still won’t let it pay.

    Four 2025–26 surveys agree: shoppers let AI agents recommend and fill a basket, not pay. What agents check before they recommend you, and what merchants control.

  6. BrightonSEO next week will be full of AI claims nobody can mark wrong

    BrightonSEO is on 8 and 9 October. Here are the AI sessions I'll be watching, and what would make each one checkable.

Questions I'm working on

Most of these are not written yet. They are listed as questions, not conclusions, with the evidence on this site that each one would start from. An essay only gets published when it has an argument worth disagreeing with.

QuestionThemeEvidence so far
If Google answers before it shows a link, what is a website for?The future of websites and publishersWritten: the essay. Evidence: 40 of 40 questions answered above the first link
Is “search” still one thing, or two different habits sharing a name?Traditional search and generative AIFuture of Search Report 2026
Who checks the answer when nobody clicks through to the source?Trust and information qualityUndated figures in AI answers, the follow-up test
Does blocking AI crawlers protect a publisher, or just remove it from the answer?Publishers and AIUK news robots.txt, November 2026
Can “AI visibility” be measured well enough to manage?Search measurement13 trackers checked, how many prompt runs
Which SEO assumptions has nobody actually tested?Industry assumptionsSearch Experiment Lab, statistics traced to source
What happens to small businesses when a recommendation replaces a ranking?Changes in digital visibilityWhich UK retailers AI tools name
Is being cited worth anything if nobody visits?How people discover informationCrawled is not cited, AI citation tracker
Why do rank trackers and searchers now see different results?Search engine behaviourGoogle is lying to your rank tracker on purpose
What would change my mind about any of this?Independent thinkingThe ledger, including the calls I got wrong

Disagree with something here? Tell me. Corrections are handled under the editorial policy.